Volkswagen Logo Critique

The Volkswagen Group’s core values are “accountability, teamwork, servant’s attitude, and integrity.” In 2015, my first Volkswagen Touareg sat in front of the house for a full year before I could drive it. Each day that I saw the cream-colored car sitting there, the excitement to be able to drive it grew. Before I could remember, I was driving through town, windows down, blasting some country music. A few months later, we traded it in for another Volkswagen, this time it was a Tiguan, leased, smaller, blue, yet still iconic throughout my last year in high school. This past year, because of COVID-19, the company offered incredible deals, leading us to buy a 2020 Volkswagen Tiguan SE. Being at school, without a car, I drive around with friends and point out my car on the street every time I see one. Missing home, and the long drives have made me nostalgic for the old logo while studying Volkswagen. As incredibly iconic as the old logo is, the new logo just doesn’t live up to the luxurious spark that Volkswagen stands for.

The 2012-2019 Logo
The 2019-Present Logo

As a company, their team is committed to upholding complete satisfaction for all of their customers. Their written goal is “to offer attractive, safe and environmentally sound vehicles which can compete in an increasingly tough market and set world standards in their respective class.” Volkswagen is one of the largest automotive giants in the world. Germany housed the first Volkswagen and eventually, their name made its way around the world. The Volkswagen Group holds 12 other automobile brands under their roof. They manufacture cars for their own brand and sell in 171 countries. Some examples of the 12 brands they have under their name are Audi, Bentley, Bugatti, and Porsche, to name just a few. 

I found this quote on Volkswagens website, “The realignment of Volkswagen’s brand design is one of the world’s largest rebranding campaigns.” With this in mind, the new Volkswagen logo was created around July of 2019 to establish a younger, more modern visual. I think the redesigned logo is boring and bland with little to no detail compared to past logos. With the brand’s identity so recognizable and being one of the largest rebranding campaigns, I think they could have added a little detail to the work.

When comparing this logo to the other large motor companies that I named above, the updated Volkswagen logo failed to give off a luxurious aesthetic seen with the other brands’ logos. Although the smooth edges and crisp angles are pleasing to the eye, the logo has the ability to be scaled and still be recognized. Far away and small or close up and large, it holds relevance. It is hard for a new simple logo to slow a business like this from large sales from such a popularized brand name. I find it crazy how the designers worked on this logo for weeks, months, and maybe even years to get to the point where it is incredibly simplistic. 

Creating a logo after being established for 84 years takes immense pressure for the designers. With the last logo redesign from 2012, the detail and visual expertise vary exponentially between the two. They both still hold the iconic circle incorporated with the ‘V’ above the ‘W’ within it on the solid color background. In my opinion, the particular line work, detail, and tone changes with a touch of shine and dimension in the 2012 version are visible and recognizable in any context. While the 2019 logo may be the ninth design created for the large corporation, it still holds significant power. The thinning of the lines as a whole seems almost too simple for how advanced the technology has become. I think the new logo is lifeless with little detail but still can be recognized almost anywhere. This logo lacks dimension and leaves for an extremely minimalist aesthetic. 

Another important consideration when thinking about updating a company logo is whether it aligns with societal expectations. This logo was designed to appeal to the target population the company is looking to sell to. But, I think Volkswagen’s new and improved logo lacks the luxurious feel, as I stated previously, which may be displeasing to some. Some people buy cars to show it off, by minimizing the detail and the shine on the logo, it takes that fancy and expensive feeling away. In the coming years, I am interested in seeing where this design is taken and whether that be more detailed or less detailed than the current one. Overall, I think this updated logo design is a bit too simple for this luxurious of a brand. 

McLuhan’s Crazy Thoughts

Marshall McLuhan was a man known for being a ‘communication theorist.’ He studied how mass media is informing people. McLuhan claimed “We shape our tools, and thereafter our tools shape us” is one of his famous quotes. In a nutshell, this means that you can remember how to use Command+F when you want to search for something, and that action might become immersed in the way your mind works.

For me, the ideas he had about “hot” and “cold” mediums of media, although accurate, have changed and improved with technology. Some examples of what I am talking about regarding “hot” media are film, photography, radio, etc. “Hot” media requires an immersion in the work but can sit back and relax. “Cold” media is inclusive and requires participation and engagement. Some examples of this type of media include virtual reality, the internet, tv, and your phone.

The way we receive a particular message, perhaps a political statement, would change based on what source you are receiving it. For example, Fox News is one news source that gives its content based on opinion with a Republican perspective. On the other side of the spectrum, CNN and The New York Times are opinions based on the Democratic perspective. If you choose to view those news sources, they are center structured content that is unbiased and reliable. NPR, BBC, USA Today, and many others refrain from opinion-based news and only share creditable and accurate information.

A “global village” is a term McLuhan used to describe how electronic media is used. Everyone gets the same information at the same time, thus ‘linking all people together.’ It is taking a localized village of information and globalizing it to the public. A current provider of this information that has blown up in the last year is TikTok. This media provider has allowed for a video up to 60-seconds long to blow up and find itself onto many people’s For You pages. Social Media outlets like TikTok or Instagram have allowed a comments section for people to state their opinion. Although causing some controversy, you can sometimes dig through the comments to find some more information on the topic. One example of TikTok spreading information quickly is the explosion that happened in Beirut, Lebanon in 2020.

Explosion in Beirut Lebanon 2020 | TikTok Video Compilation from Different  Angles | Pray for Lebanon - YouTube
https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D_363kxT0pUM&psig=AOvVaw1ZGUBmlqFy7rEB1bXLmAfE&ust=1610580603845000&source=images&cd=vfe&ved=0CAIQjRxqFwoTCICQh7rGl-4CFQAAAAAdAAAAABAD

When considering how media changes from different views, I believe that it will change the way I approach things. Being quick to judge or believe what I see off the bat will be one step in changing my approach. Fact-checking, researching, and looking at unbiased sources is a great way to improve the way I view and receive media. When I work on design projects, I want to make sure I understand the back story and information that I need to make sure it is thorough and transparent.

This is new…

Hello, people of this wild world that we live in. My name is Emma Binstein, although many call me Binny. I have come here today to introduce myself to you all. I was born in the suburbs of Illinois and moved to the small resort town of Whitefish, Montana at the age of 2. This town is the definition of small-town living, there is 1 elementary school, 1 middle school, and 1 high school, basically meaning everyone knows everyone. I grew up dancing during the week and going skiing on the weekends. Life was pretty simple at that age.

Fast forward 16 years, and I move to Corvallis, OR. Placed into a tiny dorm room surrounded by 35,000 students without knowing a single person. Talk about a fresh start. It wasn’t until a few months in that I began to meet all these amazing new people and truly learned to understand the importance of getting out of my home state. Thus bringing a larger appreciation for visiting home.

Coming into college, Interior Design in the College of Business was what I was set on. After realizing I like the creative side of design midway through my Winter term, I switched to a Graphic Design major in the College of Liberal Arts, possibly one of the best decisions I ever made.

In high school, I took digital design during my freshman year and then media communications my senior year. This allowed me to have a semi-solid base going into college. Starting in the application class during Spring term was a bit nerve-wracking and unknown, then I began to understand the art of Graphic Design, and the perfectionism it takes, which is what first drew me to it initially.

A long time ago, some friends asked me the common question: What do you want to do with a Graphic Design major? Off the top of my head, I said “I think it would be awesome to design skis, snowboards, and skateboards.” Since that day, I have hoped one day, I will be skiing down the mountain on my own custom made skis.