Since gray wolves have been listed on the ESA, their recovery has gone exceedingly well, even prompting removal from being considered “threatened” or “endangered” in certain regions of the United States. Due to the significant amount of wolf populations that have become self-sustaining throughout the U.S., the shift in recovery now has many wolf populations designated as “non-essential, experimental populations” under the ESA. Much of the focus now is on ensuring the continued conservation of wolves as top predators, while also protecting the social and economic interests of those who may be directly impacted by the increase in wolf populations (e.g. cattle ranchers).
What is the evidence to support or to oppose species listing?
There is ample evidence to support the delisting of the gray wolf Canis lupus from the Endangered Species Act. In 2009, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) published a rule in the Federal Register to delist the species in a portion of North American states. The rule reports that a healthy, distinct population segment of the gray wolf within the Northern Rocky Mountains (NRM) supports the revision of the gray wolf’s listing in the states that the NRM encompasses (Washington State, Oregon, Utah, and Idaho) except Wyoming (FWS 2009).
What is the status of habitat for the species?
As a species, the North American gray wolf (Canis Lupus) is characterized by high mobility. The historical range of the gray wolf is the largest of any extant terrestrial mammal. The expanse of their biogeographical range also encompasses a variety of ecosystems: from dense forest to open grassland; and even as drastically from Arctic tundras to extreme deserts (Geffen et. al 2004). This broad range effectively classifies this species as habitat generalists. Albeit, even though the gray wolf (Canis lupus) has the potential to be ubiquitous in a variety of ecosystems does not mean that it is actually present in each of those ecosystems. This is because the distribution patterns of large carnivores like the gray wolf (Canis lupus) are strongly influenced by environmental discontinuity, human persecutions and other human activities (De La Ville et. al 1998). The implication of these sensitivities is that the realized niche, the range it actually occupies, is significantly smaller than its fundamental niche, the total amount of habitat it could utilize in theory. Finally, when we consider other factors such as habitat fragmentation by way of human encroachment, insurmountable topographic barriers such as mountains ranges and large bodies of water, and reluctance to disperse across these barriers, the final range that the gray wolf(Canis lupus) has to exist in is in grave danger.
What are the primary threats to the species?
The primary threat to gray wolves (Canis lupus) would be either from humans killing or trapping gray wolves, or from habitat loss. Historically these have been the downfall of the gray wolf (Canis lupus) in the lower 48 states, so it would make sense that these threats still remain present, especially given the relatively small population of reintroduced wolves. Back in the late 1800s as ranchers and hunters began pushing out further west, they began to encounter more and more wolves and they also started using more wolf territory as farmland. This led to wolves having less space and less available prey options which caused them to eat the livestock of the farmers. This caused a great push by farmers and hunters to eradicate the gray wolf from the western US and they were successful. Today, wolves still cause problems for farmers in the areas where they have been reintroduced and so the threat of farmers deciding to fight back against the wolves still remains, although there are now much greater legal protections for the wolves. In addition, much of the gray wolves previous habitat is being used by humans and so wolf populations will always face the threat of habitat loss. Lastly, only 66 wolves were reintroduced, meaning that genetic diversity could potentially be a concern for the longevity of the wolves. For example, if a disease were to spread between the wolf packs, it’s possible that all the wolves would be eradicated if none of those original 66 carried a gene that was resistant to the disease.
Gray Wolf (canis lupus). SN bighorn sheep. (n.d.). Retrieved October 25, 2021, from https://www.sierraforestlegacy.org/FC_SierraNevadaWildlifeRisk/GrayWolf.php.