If I had to choose between Avery and Jaime, I would hire Jaime. While Avery might have higher potential and occasionally deliver incredible work, the lack of motivation and initiative would make it very difficult to work with her. Even the most talented person is hard to rely on if they do not show up consistently or need to be pushed just to get the basics done. In a role that is essential to my business, I need someone dependable who takes ownership of their responsibilities and can be trusted to follow through. Jaime may not have the same peak performance as Avery, but they show up every day ready to work, take initiative, and deliver results. That kind of consistency and reliability is far more valuable to me in the long run.
That said, there are jobs where someone like Avery could be the right fit. Roles that revolve around creativity or breakthrough performance, such as a freelance designer, consultant, or innovator, could benefit from her potential. In these types of jobs, success might come from a few standout moments rather than everyday performance. If managed correctly and motivated by the right project, Avery’s talent could make a huge impact, even if she is not reliable day to day.
On the other hand, Jaime would be perfect for positions that require strong routines and steady output, like customer service, operations, or team coordination. These jobs need someone who not only shows up but also takes initiative and solves problems consistently. Jaime brings that level of dedication and dependability, which is essential for keeping a business running smoothly.