Liminal Space: Belonging and UDL 3.0

This is a guest post by Winter 2025 Ecampus Instructional Design Intern Terrence Scott.

Creating Online Learning Spaces Where Adult Learners Belong

Today’s college students are increasingly adults returning to education to pursue career shifts, personal growth, or new credentials. Yet, this return often brings discomfort. Adult learners find themselves in a liminal space, caught between who they were and who they are becoming as students. This “in-between” state is a psychological and social threshold where identity and belonging are in flux (Maksimović, 2023; Turner, 1969).

Liminal space is defined as “characterized by the questioning and reexamination of one’s identity, often as a result of transitional moments in an individual’s life such as separation, loss, and conflicts” (Maksimović, 2023). Rather than a moment, adult learners experience the entire educational journey—from enrollment to graduation—as a liminal space. Supporting learners through this journey requires intentional course design that centers on inclusion and belonging.

Online Learning as a Threshold

As Johnson (2022) and Maksimović (2023) describe, adult learners often navigate identity shifts as they move from familiar roles in work or family life into the unfamiliar space of studenthood. For some, prior negative school experiences further intensify feelings of isolation during this transition.

Adult learners in liminal space often struggle with:

Imposter Syndrome: “Am I really capable of doing this?”

Identity Conflict: “Am I a student now, or still just a working professional?”

Social Isolation: “Do I belong here, or am I too different from my classmates?”

Fear of Failure: “What if I don’t succeed and let myself or my family down?”

Without a strong sense of belonging, these feelings can lead to disengagement or dropout. But when courses are designed to recognize this liminal space, learners are more likely to persist and thrive (Mezirow, 1991).

The Role of Belonging in Adult Learning

Belonging is a powerful driver of student success, especially for those from nontraditional backgrounds. It’s not just about showing up—it’s about feeling seen, respected, and included. When learners experience psychological safety and validation, motivation and commitment grow (Strayhorn, 2019).

How Does Belonging Develop?

Representation: Course content should reflect diverse identities and lived experiences.

Identity Validation: Recognize the knowledge adult learners bring with them.

Connection: Encourage interaction through group work, discussion forums, or mentorship.

Flexibility: Design with life responsibilities in mind—multiple paths to participation and success.

These elements help learners cross the threshold from “outsider” to “insider,” evolving from questioning their role in higher education to fully embracing it.

UDL 3.0: Designing for Inclusion and Belonging

Universal Design for Learning offers a framework for inclusive online course design. The latest iteration, UDL 3.0, centers identity, belonging, and engagement more explicitly than ever (CAST, 2024). It urges instructors to create spaces where students feel welcomed and recognized, not just accommodated.

How UDL Supports Adult Learners in Liminal Spaces

Engagement: Make content relevant with real-world examples, reflection exercises, and collaborative activities.

Representation: Use varied media—text, video, podcasts, interactive tools—and include voices that reflect learners’ identities.

Action & Expression: Offer multiple ways to demonstrate understanding with flexible formats, low-stakes practice, and accommodations for life’s demands.

When courses reflect these principles, adult learners gain the confidence to move through uncertainty and emerge with a stronger academic identity.

Conclusion

Liminal spaces—the uncertain, transitional moments in adult learning—can be both challenging and transformative. While some learners struggle with identity shifts, imposter syndrome, or social isolation, institutions that prioritize belonging and inclusive design can help them navigate these transitions successfully.

Higher education can foster a sense of belonging and empowerment for adult learners by integrating UDL 3.0 principles into course design and student support services. Welcoming students, valuing their diverse experiences, and establishing supportive learning environments are essential to addressing students’ unique needs and ensuring their success.

References

CAST (2024). UDL Guidelines 3.0: Universal Design for Learning.

De Abreu, K. (2023, August 7). Extreme coming of age rituals. ExplorersWeb. Link

Johnson, K. (2022). Beginning, Becoming and Belonging: Using Liminal Spaces to Explore How Part-Time Adult Learners Negotiate Emergent Identities. Widening Participation and Lifelong Learning, 24(2).

Maksimović, M. (2023). Insights from Liminality: Navigating the Space of Transition and Learning. Sisyphus–Journal of Education, 11(1).

Mezirow, J. (1991). Transformative dimensions of adult learning. Jossey-Bass.

Turner, V. (1969). The ritual process: Structure and anti-structure. Cornell University Press.

Strayhorn, T. L. (2019). College Students’ Sense of Belonging: A Key to Educational Success for All Students (2nd ed.). Routledge.