At the recent conference Song for the Blue Ocean, sponsored  by the  Spring Creek Project, it was especially pleasing to hear the high regard for OSU’s  marine science activities, and to hear and see the inspiring presentations by our own faculty and staff.

The event wove the best new science into the context of the best in literature, ethics, and art about the ocean. It was evident that OSU gives thoughtful, informed trans-disciplinary attention to our oceans and our earth, and that we offer the expertise to help further understanding and addressing of the immense challenges.

To introduce featured speaker Julia Whitty,cover of Deep Blue Home book, with turtle seen underwater. I expressed appreciation of her  exemplary style of communicating about science, making important information not only accessible but also memorable and beautiful.

Here are three examples in which I have selected  particular (uncited) chunks of the peer-reviewed literature and some of Julia Whitty’s treatment of the same subject:

Here’s how we oceanographers described one of the most revolutionary discovers of ocean chemistry:
The surface ocean is everywhere saturated with respect to calcium carbonate (CaCO3). Yet increasing atmospheric CO2 reduces ocean pH and carbonate ion concentrations [COH2−] and thus the level of saturation.

Reduced saturation states are expected to affect marine calcifiers even though it has been estimated that all surface waters will remain saturated for centuries. When atmospheric CO2 reaches 550 ppmv, in year 2050 under the IS92a business-as-usual scenario, Southern Ocean surface waters begin to become undersaturated with respect to aragonite, a metastable form of CaCO3. These changes will threaten high-latitude aragonite secreting organisms including cold-water corals, which provide essential fish habitat, and shelled pteropods, an abundant food source for marine predators.

Here’s how Julia describes it:
“Increasing levels of carbon dioxide are incrementally acidifying the World Ocean, and experiments now suggest that the shells and skeletons of everything from phytoplankton to Sea monster painting by Bob Eggletonreef-building corals will begin to dissolve within 48 hours of exposure to the acidity expected by the year 2100.  One forecast predicts that the rising levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide will condemn coral reefs – the seas’ most biodiverse realms and food sources for one in six humans – to extinction within fifty years.  Jœrmungandr, the world serpent, is chewing the bones of her tail, one vertebra, one seashell at a time.”

Let’s try PHYSICS

The physical oceanographers:  Substituting the above given values in the conservation equation gives, for Vo and V, 1.09 Sv and 30.65 Sv respectively. This simple scheme illustrates the thermohaline nature of the fresh water redistribution where the northward mass transport in the upper layer is 29.04 Sv and the southward transport in the bottom layer is 30.11Sv.

Now Julia:

“The changeover between these two currents occurs near the northern reach of the Gulf Stream’s range, around Greenland, Iceland and Norway.  In these high latitudes, the warm surface waters shed their heat to the cold, windy Arctic air – incidentally warming Europe.  As the water cools, it also evaporates, resulting in fewer water molecules in relation to salt.  This cooler, saltier Gulf Stream, now too dense to remain afloat, dives down, a process known as the

meridional overturning circulation – a transformation as profound as that of a moon jellyfish polyp becoming a medusa.”

And finally, BIOLOGY
Whale-falls represent localized areas of extreme organic enrichment in an otherwise oligotrophic deep-sea environment.  These results indicate that whale-falls can favor the establishment of metabolically and phylogenetically diverse methanogen assemblages, resulting in an active near-seafloor methane cycle in the deep sea.

Julia:

“On the vast desert of the ocean floor, a whale fall is an unexpected oasis literally dropping out of the blue and providing a nutritional bonanza of a magnitude that might otherwise take thousands of years to accumulate from the background flow of small detritus from the surface. A 35-ton gray whale takes one and a half years to be stripped to the bone by the scalpels and stomachs of the deep.”

__

Aerial view of OSU campus.When I was a graduate student at OSU, I thought that I had no need to know about any other field than the one on which I was focusing. It was not unusual, several decades back, to stay pretty closely confined in one’s own small disciplinary world: a mono-disciplinary culture, if you will.

Trends in the eighties and nineties led to considerable treatment of both multi- and inter-disciplinary research. The distinction, in my mind, can be described  as follows:

  • There’s little connective tissue of the research in a multi-disciplinary effort. Typically, the data are combined simply for the context of completeness, without a consideration of any interdependence.
  • An inter-disciplinary effort is one in which the critical dependencies between the fields are recognized, and there is a well-defined effort to find the intersection of solutions between the fields. The emergence of the field of biogeochemistry is a good example.

We’re now in the era of transdisciplinarism. In this mode, the scientists recognize not only the value of the different fields of study toward a common problem, but there is also a clear need or desire on the part of the scientists to become somewhat fluent in their complementary areas of research. I’ve seen this boldly expressed here at OSU in the field of ecoinformatics, in which mathematicians, ecologists and computer scientists are eagerly engaging in the challenges of each other’s fields. It’s a very exciting and energizing concept which – I believe – represents a strong core value we should embrace in the development of the OSU Research agenda.

-Rick Spinrad, VP for [Transdisciplinary!] Research

I would like to hear your thoughts on this subject.
To comment, open a specific blog entry by clicking on its title (rather than staying the general “archives” page) and scroll down to the “reply” section.