Reflect on your experience in the interviews you’ve participated in. Drawing on the readings and lectures from this week, what made those interviews effective and possibly ineffective, especially when you think about reliability, validity, and utility? If you could go back and advise those employers on how to improve the effectiveness of their interviews, what would you tell them?
When considering my previous experience with interviews and being interviewed, a specific story comes to mind. I interviewed with a local business, and looking back on this experience with more education behind me I have some thoughts on how that interview could have been more effective for both me, and the potential employer.
I was asked if I could interview short notice within a few hours, which was inconvenient, however while trying to make a positive impression I made it work with my schedule. When I arrived, my interview begun late and was with the entire staff of the office, which had added some pressure to perform well. Additionally, the person who was primarily interviewing me seemed upset that I was a college student, which was clearly listed on my resume, and seemed more concerned with my appearance and personality, rather than my skills, education, and experiences. I also had realized in the interview, where the entire staff of the office sat in, the entire staff was young women, besides the older male supervisor who was the one primarily conducting the interview. The supervisor seemed unpleased with all my responses to the interview questions and talked more about himself and his accomplishments than the job position. As an interviewee, this experience left a pretty bad taste in my mouth and even as I was offered the position, I did not feel comfortable accepting it. I could tell that this was not a workplace where I would have been supported, my time and effort valued, and I had concerns about the workplace culture.
On the other end of the spectrum, my latest interview for the position I am currently in, asked specific questions about my experience and skills, offered hypotheticals to respond to, seemed that they had looked over and remembered details from my resume, and portrayed a work culture that was supportive and one that I wanted to be apart of. It was a handful of interviewers and myself, in a private conference room, and they were all incredibly friendly and seemed to value my time. An interview is not just for the employer to pick the best candidate, but also for an employee to find the right fit for them. The interview is the first impression for both the employee and employer, and some behaviors can send the wrong impression that can deter potential candidates, such as my first experience I detailed in this post.
In one scenario, I felt that there was a lot of bias in the questions and responses I was receiving from the employer. The interview was also unstructured, unprofessional, and was in the middle of an office setting with many (probably 10 all together) participants interviewing me that were staff and not management. The supervisor also allowed his entire staff to ask me whatever questions they felt necessary, which led to a lot of tangents on my personal life and theirs. The interviewer did not take notes or really pay attention to my responses to the questions, and just overall felt like a waste of everyone’s time. . In the other scenario, I felt respected. The interview was structured with written down questions I was able to refer to during my answers, in a private setting, with only interviewers in the room. Rapport was established, and by the end we were all chatting and being friendly, and I knew that was a work culture I wanted to be apart of. This really emphasized to me the importance of an interview in how it establishes the relationship an employee or candidate may have with a potential employer and sets the tone for the position. Had my first interview been more professional, less biased, and respectful, I may have wanted to join their team, however the interview was several red flags that left me to look for other positions. By taking the time and effort to plan and structure an interview to be effective you can attract more qualified candidates, reinforce your company culture, and lessen the impacts of bias in the workplace.