By: Hudson Chase
Labor unions continue to play a strong role in shaping wages, workplace safety, and employee protections across many industries. From an employee perspective, unions offer clear financial and job security benefits. Research shows that “union workers in the United States earn approximately one third more than nonunion workers” (Baker, Stock, and Velazquez, 701), which highlights the economic advantage of collective bargaining. Unions also provide protection during workplace conflict, as “the union will defend an employee faced with discipline or dismissal” (D.O. CAPS, 3). These protections reinforce what we learned in class about how unions help create stability and fairness for workers.
From an employer standpoint, unions can offer structure and consistency through clearly defined contracts, but they may also increase labor costs and reduce managerial flexibility. Negotiations, strikes, and rigid work rules can place pressure on productivity and profits. At the societal level, unions have historically helped raise wages, strengthen safety laws, and expand worker rights. However, modern labor policy has shifted power away from unions. As one source explains, “So-called right-to-work laws have always been sold as all-American protections of individual freedoms. But they are in fact dangerous, confusing restrictions on Americans’ basic rights on the job” (Shermer, 2018). This contrasts with earlier labor history when unions played a stronger role in shaping workplace standards.
After comparing course material with outside research and real world examples, my key takeaway is that unions are most effective in industries where safety risks are high, wages are unstable, and workers lack a voice. Personally, I would consider joining a union in a job where protections were weak or conditions were unsafe. In a professional environment that already provides fair wages, growth opportunities, and open communication, I would be less likely to seek union membership unless those conditions changed.
Sources:
Shermer, Elizabeth Tandy. “The Right to Work Really Means the Right to Work for Less.” The Washington Post, 24 Apr. 2018.
Baker, Robin, Laura Stock, and Valeria Velazquez. The Role of Labor Unions. 2011.
D.O. CAPS. Human Relations: Unions and Employee Organizations.
