I’ve been working at Enterprise Computing Services at Oregon State University as a student developer for one year. In our group, we mainly focused on developing Application Programing Interface (API) and other relevant jobs. As a Computer Science major graduate student, real-world working experience gave me a very good opportunity to apply my academic knowledge and concepts to practical situations. Since there are various tools involved in software development, a student developer should learn and be able to use these tools very quickly.

Last summer, I worked on a big project which utilized two open source tools, Ansible and Jenkins, to automate our APIs’ deployment process and implement the concept of continuous integration. Because of this project, I got a chance to demo and present my work in front of lots of audiences including stakeholders. Being able to state the concept clearly to audiences is also a very important skill as a professional software developer. From my experience, these areas are important to any student who wants to become a professional developer.

  • Always practice and enhance your coding skill. Pick one or two programming languages you are familiar the most and keep practicing them. If possible, you can also choose some frameworks (e.g. Django or Flask) to implement your own project. Push them to GitHub so that people can easily view your technical skills and enthusiasm.
  • Writing skill is also important. As time goes by, it is easy to forget details of a project you worked on. Therefore, being able to write clear explanations of a project with well-documented documentation can help you and your teammates save a lot of time.
  • Time management. Manage your time wisely especially when you are a student and also a software developer at the same time. Scheduling your tasks by priorities is always a good idea and it helps you finish your tasks on time and efficiently.
  • Finally, good communication is the most critical skill you definitely need to have. From regular group meetings to large meetings across the departments, you will have many opportunities to demo your work or convince other people. Having a strong communication skill will absolutely help you and your team a lot.

In a nutshell, developing your technical skills and soft skills are equivalently important for a professional software developer. Student or whoever is able to show the above abilities will definitely be a good software developer. Remember that opportunity favors the prepared mind. Hope all future student developers can find a great journey here!

For the past year and a half, I’ve been working in two teams in Information Services at OSU as a student developer. My first year in SIG (Shared Infrastructure Group) gave me an opportunity to work on the open source CoprHD project and regularly collaborate with the community members and the developers from the industry. As the team leader, besides the work assigned to me, I was also responsible for tracking the progress of my team members, assuring the on-time delivery of the features. Giving presentations of our work based on different purposes to the audience from various backgrounds was another important part of this project.

My role in the second team was one of the developers in the team. This team involved more diverse tasks allowing me to grasp many skills in a short period. Similar to the previous work, presentations were also frequent activities. Team members share knowledge through demoing or explaining the work to the team members. On the other hand, I went through several interviews for the past year, which gave me a sense of desired skills in the industry. If I look back to the experiences of interview processes and my job, there are some tips I could share with the students who want to be developers, and some of which I wish I could have done better.

Communication Skills

I know this might sound cliche, but it is one of the most highly effective skills that can help you reach your goal whether to get the work done or the help you need. Specifically, being able to ask questions wisely will bring you the answer you need, reduce avoidable mistakes or get out of the tar pits. In addition, communication over emails is another routine. A clear and concise email not only shows your professionality but also leads up to prompt replies.

Moreover, as described above, presentations are commonplace at work, so being capable of showing your work through the presentations is not just desirable but also necessary. During interviews, it’s very likely to be asked to introduce the projects you have done, while at work it’s even more frequent to demonstrate your work/ideas to your team or even a larger audience. Therefore, capable of delivering your thoughts clearly or even vividly will be a big plus in the job market.

Technical Skills

Technical skills are your core competencies, and it’s very critical to keep strengthening the skills you already have. Further, being able to learn new skills and learn them quickly on demand might be even more valuable. It is very common that you are not familiar some of the techniques used in your project, which can be a programming language, a framework or a tool. Being able to grasp the knowledge and applying them to the project is also a demonstration of your ability to work.

Another suggestion is to be aware of your thought process and try to identify and form the most efficient one for yourself. The thought process, such as how you learn things, how you debug and how you figure out a problem will change over time along with your experience. And an awareness of the changes will help you improve your efficiency, which is also helpful for your interviews since a lot of interviewers will try to identify your thought process from the way you answer their questions.

Additionally, putting down the notes for the work you have done is one of the things that I wish I could have done better. No matter how confident you thought you would remember the work, after leaving it aside for couple months or even weeks, everything will look completely new to you.

In a nutshell, technical skills and the communication skills are the way to becoming a professional developer. I believe if one could continue enhancing the skills discussed above and be able to show them to the employers, he/she will be a strong hire in the job market.

I’ve been working in IT at OSU as a student for the past 3 years, but more recently, I’ve been taking more of the responsibilities of a developer over the course of this year. Growing into the role as a student developer with my job has been well-timed with my degree in Business Information Systems. My undergraduate studies this past academic year as a senior has involved more software architecture and development leading up to my graduation. The similarities between the work I’ve done for my job and for my degree have been complimentary, allowing me to share skills and techniques between the two disciplines.
Taking classes in a business environment has given me a different prospective on software development for my work. Information systems business classes, besides teaching programming, focused on making sure the outcome of software development is successful and addresses the needs of stakeholders. We were taught to focus on the problem trying to be solved, conceptualize a solution in a non-technical way to stakeholders, and develop measures of success to ensure the outcome isn’t a failure. These skills along with my experience as a developer guide some of the advice I have for students who want to be developers:
  • Be able to communicate non-technically when needed. Whether it be a supervisor, customer, or colleague in a different department. Being in a software development role means taking on the work that requires special skills and knowledge unique to you and your team. The ability to propose a better solution to a problem, explain an issue to a stakeholder, or even describing the work being done to someone who isn’t as technically proficient is key. I’ve always believed that being able to teach a topic or skill is a marker of proficiency in that area, and when it comes to software development and IT, being able to communicate something non-technically is a similar marker of proficiency. 
  • Remember the importance of soft skills like verbal communication, demo/presentation skills, and writing skills. According a survey conducting by Technical Councils of North America 70% of employers say soft skills are equally important as technical skills for success in a software development career. My experience in IT and software development has taught me the importance of these soft skills. It has always been beneficial for me to keep up with these skills through practice, whether it’s giving a demo at work or a presentation for a class.
  • Learn and practice technical skills through projects and practical experience. Learning technical skills is very important, but I would advise aspiring developers to practice and maintain their skills through methods that are demonstrable to employers. Being able to show a coding project or talk about projects accomplished during a job or internship might be required during the interview or application process. The knowledge of development skills serves as a foundation, but being able to demonstrate those skills is important for pursuing a career as a developer.
At the end of the day, good technical skills will be at the core of software development. However, getting in to software development as a career can be difficult without much prior experience. I believe demonstrating the skills above can show employers that someone is able to grow into a developer position to further diversify their technical and soft skills.

The ERP system that we use is Banner. There are some big architectural changes that we’ve been adopting. This translates into some changes on how we do development. We will try to summarize them in this post.

Revision Control

We were using SVN to manage code that our vendor provided. The code is now provided via git repositories! This meant that we needed to store these git repositories locally. Other units within Information Services in the past used GitLab ( https://about.gitlab.com ) . GitLab is a good open source solution, but our previous experience with it showed us that the monthly updated usually broke some aspect of functionality and the upgrades were painful due to rails / ruby version updates. We went with GitHub Enterprise ( https://enterprise.github.com/home ) . 

We talked to another couple of schools that used GitHub Enterprise (for other types of development) and they were very happy with the UI and maintenance. Our experience with upgrades to GitHub enterprise have been painless. Features and changes to the GitHub platform first appear in public github.com and after a couple of months we’ll see them come to an upgrade in GitHub Enterprise. 

The change of svn to git is not an easy change for our developers. The change from a centralized server such as svn where we mostly used TortoiseSVN as a client to a decentralized system such as git is a big change. We tried using Code School to provide devs with access to great git tutorials. The issue was that due to work related commitments and devs not actively using git, the training wasn’t effective. Our next plan of action is to have group git exercises in a frequent basis. This will expose developers to using git more frequently and use the new scm features that a decentralized system such as git provides. For GUI clients we recommend using SourceTree ( https://www.sourcetreeapp.com ) and within Linux we use the command line since that’s easier.

Development Environment

Our developers use Windows for development. When we started to experiment with Banner XE development, we ran into roadblocks. Having to manage different versions of Java or Grails in Windows is not easy. In *nix environments, we have tools such as SDKMAN ( http://sdkman.io ) to manage the versions of JVM tools. It took us days to get Grails applications and their dependencies properly running in Windows. That’s when we realized that Windows could work, but trying to replicate this setup in each developer workstation was going to be a nightmare. 

To make lives easier we used VirtualBox ( https://www.virtualbox.org ) and created a VM using Ubuntu. In this VM, we setup the various Java and Grails dependencies to build Grails Banner applications. By having a single VM, we could setup the dependencies and configure the JVM tools once and all the developers could leverage a single installation. We had a Google doc that specified how to setup and configure the dependencies. It was several pages long and mostly due to screenshots in Windows. On the other hand, the Linux instructions were much shorter and could be scripted.

Using VMs was great, but we started to run into some memory problems. Our development machines were about 4-5 years old with 16GB of RAM and non-ssd hard drives. The grails applications that we are dealing with easily require 3-4GB of RAM each. We also use Intellij IDEA Ultimate within VirtualBox. We found that Intellij IDEA worked properly within VirtualBox. To be on the safe side, we give a total of 6G of ram to VirtualBox. This meant that developers couldn’t run many applications in their machines. Web browsers use a lot of memory and trying to run two VirtualBox VMs concurrently wasn’t possible.

To support development, developers got new machines. The new workstations have 32G of ram and an SSD. A new CPU and GPU were also part of the upgrade, but we didn’t find them to be a constraint with the previous machines. The SSD provided some improvements for Windows, but once VirtualBox is running the SSD doesn’t make a huge difference. I would still recommend to others to upgrade to a new SSD and RAM if possible. It is a very cheap upgrade and you will run out of RAM.


In order to support the updated development workflow, we are using Jenkins ( https://jenkins.io/index.html ). The ESM tool provided by our ERP vendor leverages Jenkins as the underlying technology. From talking to our DBA, ESM only provides us with admin level access so it’s not something that we could easily allow devs to use, yet. We do have ESM installed, and our DBA uses it to fetch code from the vendor.

Since we have non grails based development it made sense for us to stand up a separate instance of Jenkins. We are leveraging Ansible ( https://www.ansible.com ) to setup the Jenkins, its dependencies and jobs. By using Ansible, we are able to test changes to Jenkins locally via Vagrant ( https://www.vagrantup.com ) in our workstations. We can go from a bare VM to start compiling an XE Grails application (using a jenkins job) within 5 – 7 minutes. 

Dev Practices - Ansible Automation


So far we haven’t made any custom changes to the codebase. 

  1. A Jenkins job checks daily if a new git repository is available from the ERP vendor. If there is a new one, we create a new repo in github enterprise
  2. Daily we update our GitHub Enterprise repos with any new commits, branches and tags from the vendor

Dev Practices - Vendor Code Upates

The development workflow that we plan to use is the following:

  1. Use three git branches that mirror our instances for each application. One environment is production and the other two are development / test.
  2. When a developer wants to make a change to either the development or test environment, they would create a feature branch. The feature branch’s name is a ticket-id (from our bug tracker) and two / three word description of the change. This allows us to track a change / back to a developer and why the change is being made.
  3. We want to commit early and often to the feature branches. Once the code is ready, we’ll use GitHub’s Pull Requests to do reviews. 
  4. Jenkins jobs can be leveraged to perform checks on the code.
  5. Once the code is ready to be deployed to either the test or dev environment, a Jenkins job will generate a war file for our DBA.
  6. Our DBA then uses ant scripts provided by our ERP vendor to deploy the WAR file to Tomcat.

Dev Practices - Developer Workflow

The advantages of using Jenkins to compile the code is that we make sure there are no local code changes or dependencies in a developer’s workstations needed to compile code and not present in GitHub Enterprise. All war files are compiled in the same manner (JVM version, dependencies, etc). Naming of artifacts is consistent and Jenkins can send notifications when builds fail. Developers can review previous builds, generate new war files, and examine failed builds.

Next Steps

Some of our next steps and improvement areas:

  • Right now we are using Google docs to document steps for developers. These need to be improved since at the time we were heavily using Windows for development.
  • If you are coming from SVN, moving to git is a big change. We plan to do git exercises as a team on a weekly basis. This will help get our developers familiar with git commands, merging, branches and dealing with git conflicts.
  • As we start to make changes to the vendor supplied code, we need to figure out what version of a grails application we are running. We need to keep track not just of the vendor’s base version, but our commits / changes. We’ll use jenkins to name war files in a way that includes the environment, vendor version and our local commit sha1.
  • Containers are the next major step for virtualization. We plan to explore how we can best run WAR file in containers for development purposes.

Ever had an hour to kill on campus and been looking for an interesting class to drop in on? Look no further. Introducing… Classy.

CS372 is meeting *right* now in Kelley Engineering Center.

Classy is a simple web app which shows you a random, currently-happening class every time you load the page. We built Classy to demonstrate the class search API that we’ve been building. All the data it needs—the list of class subjects, the current term, and most importantly all the class data—is fetched via API calls in convenient JSON format, avoiding the need to scrape any data from the catalog.

Almost all of the data in the web catalog is available, including the meeting times for the class and enrollment numbers—the only notable exception being the course description. Classy leverages some of this extra catalog data to filter out classes which are very small and non-lecture classes (it would be kind of rude to walk into a 10-person recitation, after all).

There are still a couple areas where Classy could use improvements; for example, it doesn’t understand that summer classes only run for a few weeks of the term, or that group midterms don’t happen every week.

The source code for Classy is up on Github, and as soon as the class search API is made public through the developer portal, you’ll be able play with it yourself.

Posted in API.

One of the most commonly requested public API by students has been a class/catalog API. The fact that there’s no API for class/catalog data hasn’t stopped eager student developers. They usually end up scraping data from the catalog and storing it in a database where their applications can easily access it. We are happy to say that we have started work on a solution to this common student developer problem 🙂

The API will allow developers to query classes by term, subject and course number to retrieve full class information including details, teacher, class availability and other information publicly available via the course catalog. We have started our design process in github: https://github.com/osu-mist/courses-api-design using the OpenAPI Initiative format (formerly known as Swagger). You can use the swagger editor links below to see the first draft of the design:

Let us know what you think either with a comment or pull request. This design and the first implementation of this API won’t be final. Our goal is to release a beta version of the API, and collect developer feedback.


Posted in API.

When the Hackathon rolled around our team wanted to bring a project that extended or utilized our current CMS for a new purpose. We wanted something that we could start and finish in a single day and we also wanted a project that would take advantage of a team with diverse skill sets.

Enter bennyslista classified advertisements website exclusive to the Oregon State community with sections devoted to buying and selling textbooks, electronics, bikes and just about anything students need. Students can create and respond to listings through the site, making it a safe, secure place to buy and sell.” taken directly from our about page.

Screen Shot 2016-05-18 at 2.15.46 PM

Bennyslist is a group within the main.oregonstate.edu drupal site. We decided to use our CMS because it allows us to tie into existing university themes and branding but it also gives us quick access to some powerful components.

CAS Authentication

Really at the core of the concept is that bennyslist is private to the OSU community. Craigslist fails because of the constant bombardment of spam and phishing attempts. Just try to sell anything and you will see for yourself, it can be an aggravating experience. Because OSU Drupal already has an authentication tool built into it we were easily able to specify which components would be “gated” via ONID login.

If you want to see what is available or want to post something for sale yourself then you will be required to use your OSU issued account. This was also nice because it did not add yet another account credential to store, memorize or update.


The second component that we used was Drupal Webforms. Our audience can go to the form and fill out what they have for sale and once submitted those entries are dynamically display in our listings. This allows them to come back and edit the posts and also means that it is fully automated. No staff time is required in moving submissions onto the for sale/trade list. However, it also provides a way for administrators to remove postings that are deemed unacceptable.

Screen Shot 2016-05-18 at 2.32.10 PM

Because of these components it was an easy decision to go with a centrally hosted CMS as opposed to trying to create our own home grown application. There are certainly some compromises to make, but in the end we were able to create a fully automated and functional tool.

The rest of the work went into marketing and communications. We had designers create attractive images, a writer help with copywriting and a video producer even had time to create a commercial for the tool. Taking a fully integrated approach to our product allowed us to deliver a completed product in the time allowed.

So go ahead and give it a try, think about how you use Drupal and OSU templates. They do have some limitations but that doesn’t mean you can’t explore different functionality and strategy for your sites.

The Team

  • Callie Newton – Web Editor and Writer
  • Oliver Day – Interactive Designer
  • Santiago Uceda – Assistant Director (Illustrator for this project)
  • Darryl Lai – Multimedia Producer
  • Kegan Sims – Drupal Architect

I run two email newsletters for the Graduate School. One delivered weekly through MailChimp and one monthly through lists.oregonstate.edu. The monthly newsletter is also posted to our Drupal website. I spend a lot of time on these newsletters and what follows is how I write and proof them. I also use these methods for copy editing blog posts and other types of editing and writing (minus the CSS inlining.) At the end, I’ll share some additional tools that I hope to incorporate in the future.

Write in Markdown

For me, the easiest way to write my newsletters is in Markdown. While Markdown is not an exact standard, there are enough services using it that it is fairly well supported across the web and within tools. Github supports it. BeeGit is a content writing and editing platform that uses it.

I use the Sublime Text 3 text editor with the Markdown Editing package. The Markdown Editing package gives you some special highlighting, a color scheme, and other niceties. It does not, however, provide an HTML preview. When first writing in Markdown, I used BeeGit for its preview and Markdown cheat sheet until I became more comfortable with the syntax.

Why do I use Markdown? My top reasons:

  • Conversion to HTML with Pandoc (more on this later)
  • I can use my text editor (goodbye Word)
  • The files are only plain text for maximum preservation value
  • Creating a link is a breeze
  • Creating a link is a breeze
  • Creating a link is a breeze

So yeah, creating links is a breeze. My newsletters take the format of blurb and link, blurb and link, etc. If I had to create each link using a WYSIWYG, I would find a new line of work.

Words to avoid, grammar and style

Some talented people have released tools that check your text for common errors beyond spelling mistakes. I use four of these.

Proselint focuses on usage, not grammar. Here’s a list of what it checks for. It is a command-line only tool at this time.

retext-mapbox-standard is a combination of language tools that checks for gendered language and potential slurs, words to avoid in educational writing, jargon, and more, plus it can read Markdown. The project is meant as an example of what organizations can do to enforce their own style guides, but I use it as provided by Mapbox. Also a command-line tool.

OSU copy cop is a tool I made that checks some of the editorial standards set forth by OSU. Saying “I made” isn’t really true: I copied it from the original Copy cop and added a few OSU things.

Grammerly is a web and desktop application that checks usage, grammar, spelling, and more. Available as a free tier and paid tier. I copy my text into it and out of it, which isn’t efficient, but gets the job done and it doesn’t complain about the Markdown I paste in. The available browser plugin also checks your text while you write posts on websites like Facebook and Twitter, which can help you avoid some embarrassing mistakes.

Pandoc to convert to HTML

Pandoc is a fantastic tool that converts between file types. Converting Markdown to HTML goes like this:

pandoc -o file-out.html file-in.md

That’s it and bam! HTML ready to go.

Add CSS to the header

For my monthly email newsletter I like to inline some of my CSS into the HTML, so before sending it through an inliner tool (see below) I have pandoc create a standalone HTML document with my CSS in the HEAD of that doc. If you give Pandoc the -H option it will grab the contents of that file and put it in the HEAD of the doc you are creating.

pandoc -o -s file-out.html file-in.md -H add-to-head.html

The add-to-head.html file looks like:

  p {
    margin-bottom: 1em;

Inline the CSS

Now that my HTML doc is ready with the styles in the HEAD, I can run the whole thing through an inliner tool and it will put the styles inline with my HTML. I use Mailchimp’s inliner tool for this. I think there are some command line tools for this (like Juice) but this website makes it quick.

Add to Drupal and send email

Finally, after the inliner step, my newsletter’s HTML is ready. I go to my Drupal site and paste in the HTML. From there I copy the text and paste it directly into Gmail for sending. The result is a plain, single column newsletter layout. Here’s an example.

Future improvements

I’d like to add a HTML template system (like this or this) to my workflow so I can create better layouts for the email newsletters. For that, I’ll need to go back to an email program that allows me to edit the HTML directly, like Thunderbird, or use an email service provider. For Mailchimp, WordPress, or anywhere else I just need HTML, I follow the steps above but stop after I convert the Markdown to HTML.

— John McQueen, Web Communications, Oregon State University Graduate School

The OSU Developer Portal (https://developer.oregonstate.edu) currently has two APIs available, Directory (for people) and Location (for campus locations). This post describes my experience developing a “hello world” framework with the Location API. I got excellent reuse of the framework code when also experimenting with the Directory API.

I logged on to the OSU Developer Portal, registered a new app, and got the Consumer Key and Consumer Secret strings that are required to make calls to the API.

A Consumer Key looks something like m5l2jS54r7XqkkvJVovdpUY1o4DMl0la and a Consumer Secret like koMYj5HVd9m963a8. Not the actual ones! Get yer own!

Calling an OSU API has two steps:

  1. An HTTP POST to the getAccessToken method, with Consumer Key and Consumer Secret, to get an access token.
  2. An HTTP GET to to the desired API method, here getLocations, with the access token obtained above and any optional parameters, here a q query string.

For example, calling getLocations with the query q=kerr returns this JSON:

“name”:”Kerr Administration Building”,
“summary”:”Kerr houses OSU’s top administrative offices and many services for students, including admissions, financial aid, registrar’s office and employment services. If you’d like a student-led campus tour, stop in 108 Kerr to make arrangements.”,
“address”:”1500 SW Jefferson Avenue.”,

I used the Microsoft ASP.NET Web API 2.2 Client Libraries NuGet package. This package has features to automagically deserialize JSON into plain ol’ class objects.

These are the class objects. .NET “generic” classes play an important role in the overall solution. Generic classes have a type parameter appended to their name, here <T>, where T is a naming convention used widely by .NET developers; wherever the type parameter (“T”) shows up in the class body is where the generic replacement is propagated when the type is constructed.

namespace JsonDataTransferObjects
  //first a few framework classes that can be reused later for other APIs...

  //root of all JSON returned by the OSU APIs.
  //note how the "links" and "data" fields 
  //  correspond with items of the same name in the JSON.
  public class RootObject<T>
    public Links links { get; set; }
    public List<T> data { get; set; }

  public class Links
    public string self { get; set; }
    public string first { get; set; }
    public string last { get; set; }
    public string prev { get; set; }
    public string next { get; set; }

  //Abstract (must inherit) class that corresponds to "id",
  // "type" and "attributes" of root object JSON
  public abstract class ObjectData<T>
    public string id { get; set; }
    public string type { get; set; }
    public T attributes { get; set; }

  //now classes for the solution at hand...

  //constructed type: class declared from a generic type 
  //  by supplying type arguments for its type parameters.
  //  now we will be able to work with RootObject<LocationData>,
  //  and the List in the "data" field will be of type LocationData
  public class LocationData : OregonState.Api.JsonDataTransferObjects.ObjectData<LocationAttributes>

  public class LocationAttributes
    public string name { get; set; }
    public string abbreviation { get; set; }
    public string latitude { get; set; }
    public string longitude { get; set; }
    public string summary { get; set; }
    public string description { get; set; }
    public string address { get; set; }
    public string city { get; set; }
    public string state { get; set; }
    public string zip { get; set; }
    public string county { get; set; }
    public string telephone { get; set; }
    public string fax { get; set; }
    public List<string> thumbnails { get; set; }
    public List<string> images { get; set; }
    public object departments { get; set; }
    public string website { get; set; }
    public string sqft { get; set; }
    public string calendar { get; set; }
    public string campus { get; set; }
    public string type { get; set; }
    public LocationOpenHours openHours { get; set; }

  public class LocationOpenHours
    //todo: not sure what attribute name is

Now, just enough code to get this test to pass (which it does!). Note the async and await keywords used for asynchronous programming in the .NET framework.

  public class LocationServiceIntegrationTests {
      //initialize API service client, here constructed to handle the type LocationData
      private static readonly ApiServiceClient<LocationData> myServiceClient = MerthjTestApp1ApiServiceClientFactory.CreateLocationDataApiServiceClient();
      //gotcha: even unit tests, which normally do not return anything,
      // must now be "async" and return a "Task"
      // because of "await" keyword
      async Task LocationServiceClient_Should_ReturnCorrectResultForQueryOnKerr() {
          RootObject<LocationData> result = await myServiceClient.Request("?q=kerr");
          Assert.AreEqual("Kerr Administration Building", result.data.Item[0].attributes.name);

Use factory pattern to construct the API client, because this is a complex process, and one that would lead to code duplication if simply NEW-ing the client in code.

public sealed class MerthjTestApp1ApiServiceClientFactory
	//todo: move to configuration
	// (here only because I liked to see the actual address)
	const string ApiOregonstateBaseAddressUriText = "https://api.oregonstate.edu";

	public static ApiServiceClient<LocationData> CreateLocationDataApiServiceClient()
		//pass in a new LocationService, a service which makes actual calls
		// to the API (but we could also use "mock" service here...)
		//note use of Visual Studio's "My.Resources" to store Consumer Key and Consumer Secret
		//  in a resource file; resource file SHOULD NOT EVER be checked in
		//  to revision control, or your secrets are out there for all to see.
		return new ApiServiceClient<LocationData>(new LocationService(), ApiOregonstateBaseAddressUriText, "v1/locations", My.Resources.OSU_Developer_Portal_Secrets_Resource.ConsumerKey, My.Resources.OSU_Developer_Portal_Secrets_Resource.ConsumerSecret);

An API service client is responsible for managing the access token required before each API call.

public class ApiServiceClient<T> {
    private readonly IApiService<T> myService;
    private readonly string myResourceRelativeUriText;
    private readonly string myBaseUriText;
    private readonly string myConsumerKey;
    private readonly string myConsumerSecret;
    //Lazy object is not constructed until its ".Value" method 
    // is called (a singleton) (see Me.CreateRequestAsync).
    // Not thread safe!
    private Lazy<Task<string>> myAccessToken = new Lazy<Task<string>>(new System.EventHandler(this.GetAccessTokenAsync));
    //no-arg constructor is private so clients may not use it
    private ApiServiceClient() {
    //constructor required for use by clients
    public ApiServiceClient(IApiService<T> service, string baseAddressUriText, string resourceRelativeUriText, string consumerKey, string consumerSecret) {
        // todo: validate parameters
        this.myService = service;
        this.myResourceRelativeUriText = resourceRelativeUriText;
        this.myBaseUriText = baseAddressUriText;
        this.myConsumerKey = consumerKey;
        this.myConsumerSecret = consumerSecret;
    //use the service to get the access token
    async Task<string> GetAccessTokenAsync() {
        Debug.WriteLine("Entering GetAccessTokenAsync");
        return await this.myService.GetAccessTokenAsync(this.myBaseUriText, this.myResourceRelativeUriText, this.myConsumerKey, this.myConsumerSecret);
    async Task<ApiRequest> CreateRequestAsync(string query) {
        return new ApiRequest
          //actually fetch the access token here!
          AccessToken = await this.myAccessToken.Value;
          BaseAddressUriText = this.myBaseUriText;
          ResourceRelativeUriText = this.myResourceRelativeUriText;
          Query = query;
    //clients can request API result as raw JSON string for troubleshooting...
    async Task<string> RequestAsString(string query) {
        return await this.myService.GetContentAndReadAsStringAsync(await this.CreateRequestAsync(query));
    //most clients will use this method
    async Task<RootObject<T>> Request(string query) {
        return await this.myService.GetContentAndReadAsTypeAsync(await this.CreateRequestAsync(query));

The API Service class is a messaging gateway, which encapsulates the API messaging code, and has strongly-typed methods. (See especially “public Task<RootObject> GetContentAndReadAsType(ApiRequest request)”.)

public abstract class ApiService<T> : IApiService<T>
	private static FormUrlEncodedContent CreateFormUrlEncodedContentForGetAccessToken(string consumerKey, string consumerSecret)
		//Data required by OSU Get Access Token API
		var keys = {
			new KeyValuePair<string, string>("grant_type", "client_credentials"),
			new KeyValuePair<string, string>("client_id", consumerKey),
			new KeyValuePair<string, string>("client_secret", consumerSecret)

		//Also sets content headers content type to "application/x-www-form-urlencoded".
		return new FormUrlEncodedContent(keys);

	//"Async" declaration because we are calling "GetAsync" asynchronous method.
	//.NET compiler builds an absolutely CRAZY state machine in code behind the scenes.
	private async static Task<HttpResponseMessage> GetResponseAsync(HttpClient client, ApiRequest request)
		client.DefaultRequestHeaders.Authorization = new AuthenticationHeaderValue("Bearer", request.AccessToken);

		//Await-ing a result suspends its progress and yields control to the method that called it.
		//Could actually do other things in parallel here before we Await:
		// Dim responseTask = client.Get(request.ResourceRelativeUriText & request.Query)
		// DoIndependentWork()
		// Dim response =  await responseTask

		var response = await client.Get(request.ResourceRelativeUriText + request.Query);

		//ApiService doesn't know how to handle failed responses yet, so throw exception.
		if (!response.IsSuccessStatusCode) {
			throw new InvalidOperationException(response.ReasonPhrase);

		return response;

	private static HttpClient CreateHttpClient(string baseAddressUriText)
		return new HttpClient { BaseAddress = new Uri(baseAddressUriText) };

	public Task<string> GetAccessToken(string baseAddressUriText, string resourceRelativeUriText, string consumerKey, string consumerSecret)
		//for a given resource Uri, like "v1/locations" or "v1/locations/", append segment for the access token to get "v1/locations/token"
		//todo: improve with something like http://stackoverflow.com/questions/372865/path-combine-for-urls
		var requestUri = new Uri(resourceRelativeUriText.TrimEnd('/') + "/token", UriKind.Relative);
		var content = CreateFormUrlEncodedContentForGetAccessToken(consumerKey, consumerSecret);

		//"Using" automatically and absolutely calls "Dispose" method on object at the code block.
		//Disposes any expensive and/or unmanaged resources, like an open connection stream.
		using (client = CreateHttpClient(baseAddressUriText)) {
			using (response = client.Post(requestUri, content)) {
				if (!response.IsSuccessStatusCode) {
					throw new InvalidOperationException(response.ReasonPhrase);

				//Shorthand for:
				// var response = await response.Content.ReadAs(Of GetAccessTokenResponse)()
				// Return response.access_token
				return (response.Content.ReadAs<GetAccessTokenResponse>()).access_token;

	//Read as string to support troubleshooting and curiosity.
	//Most clients should use the other method to "read as type," which reads data into strongly-typed classes
	public Task<string> GetContentAndReadAsString(ApiRequest request)
		using (client = CreateHttpClient(request.BaseAddressUriText)) {
			using (response = GetResponseAsync(client, request)) {
				return response.Content.ReadAsString();

	public Task<RootObject<T>> GetContentAndReadAsType(ApiRequest request)
		using (client = CreateHttpClient(request.BaseAddressUriText)) {
			using (response = GetResponseAsync(client, request)) {
				//The magic deserialization of JSON
				// into .NET classes happens in this one line...
				//Declaration of ReadAs is:
				//  Public Shared Function ReadAs(Of T)(content As System.Net.Http.HttpContent) As System.Threading.Tasks.Task(Of T)
				//This class (ApiService) is generic so we can take advantage of ReadAs being generic.
				return response.Content.ReadAs<RootObject<T>>();

And finally, the Location Service class inherits from API Service with the type parameter LocationData.

//Inherits ApiService, so we get its interface and functionality for free.
public class LocationService : ApiService<LocationData>

(This WordPress blog did not seem to have syntax highlighting for Visual Basic. So, I translated my existing code from VB.NET to C# using several online translators. There are bound to be errors introduced in the translation process. I know, I know. It’s not “cool” to write in VB… the poor under-appreciated language that can do everything–and more!–its currently-hip sibling C# can do. But I have more than 17 years of VB development under my belt, so not switching now just to be cool. I prefer to deliver business value rather than struggle with silly braces and semicolons. 🙂

Posted in API.

During our original exploration of APIs, we began by learning about the current space. We read books, watched webinars and used Gartner guides. One question that we couldn’t find an answer to, was what are other Universities doing with APIs? This question lead to the beginning of the API survey. The results below were shared with the ITANA mailing list in a raw format.

The list of questions was developed in collaboration with members from ITANA (a group of IT architects from Higher Ed). Due to the high number of questions, some questions were not included in the final version of the survey. In order to give more freedom to participants, the survey didn’t ask for emails or names. These results were shared with the API subgroup of ITANA via the mailing list. We are now putting the results in a blogpost to make it easier to discover in the future. If you have any questions about the survey format, design or questions, drop us a note in the comments section below.

1. What is the name of your higher education institution?
* University of Michigan
* Simon Fraser University
* University of Washington
* Virginia Tech
* The University of Toledo
* Northwestern University
* George Mason University
* Columbia University
* University of Michigan
* University of Toronto
* University Of Chicago
* Brigham Young University
* University of Wisconsin – Madison
* University of Michigan
* University of Chicago
* Johnson & Wales University
* Yale
* Minnesota State Colleges & Universities
* University of California at San Diego
* Oregon State University
* Yale University

2. What is the enrollment size of your higher education institution?

Minimum: 5,000
Max: 140,000
Average: 38,000

3. Is your higher education institution currently working on Web Services, Service Oriented Architecture?


4. What is the FTE size of the team?

2 central IT teams: 7 operating suite of REST Web Services; 10+ building new Enterprise Integration Platform (EIP)
2 FTE - infrastructure. Many FTE developers who work with web services and soa, probably over 20 known to me.

5. Is there one central department working on this effort or multiple departments?

A single central department7
Multiple departments8

6. Was this initiative setup from top management or by a small group(s) / department(s)?

A single central department7
Multiple departments8

7. What technologies are you using?

Enterprise Service Bus (ESB)7
API Gateway10

Other responses included:
* Services Registry, Message Broker
* Custom API’s, Vendor App API’s

8. What technologies are you trying to phase out, if any?
* migrating from custom .NET REST APIs to EIP with API Management
* point-to-point integrations, batch data data transfers, database links
* PeopleSoft customizations
* Direct DB connections
* Batch download
* Looking to replace custom API codebases with iPaaS solution
* custom middleware
* Hub-based Webmethods

9. Are these web services / APIs accessed by internal departments / groups within your higher ed institution, or external 3rd party vendors?

Internal departments15
3rd party vendors10

10. Where do you publish the list of web services / APIs available?
* Still in its infancy, but currently at http://www.sfu.ca/data-hub.html
* http://webservices.washington.edu/ [this is the current, custom Web Services Registry … will be migrated to an API Management tool]
* Intranet
* Services Registry
* Internal wiki
* API Manager Application
* The intent is to simply use a web page
* No central place yet. This would part of benefit of a new iPaaS that has solid API management.
* n/a
* API Manager
* https://developers.yale.edu/
* Currently don’t have a good inventory. Looking to publish a list using an API Management Service
* Planning to publish using api manager
* not published online yet

11. What’s the URL of your web services / API / SOA documentation?
* http://www.sfu.ca/data-hub/api.html
* http://webservices.washington.edu/ [also extensive UW-centric documentation in Confluence wiki sites]
* Intranet
* https://serviceregistry.northwestern.edu
* Not accessible outside
* developer.it.umich.edu
* not yet available
* No central place yet. This would part of benefit of a new iPaaS that has solid API management.
* n/a
* Not available yet
* https://developers.yale.edu/
* N/A
* Documentation is not published yet
* not published online yet

12. What is the development stack used for developing SOA / API / web services?

Java / jvm14

* and many others
* PeopleTools, WSO2 Data Services
* Custom PHP.
* PHP and Perl
* JavaScript, iOS, Android

13. What are the primary benefits you are seeing from your API strategy?
* None yet, as it’s still in its infancy. The goal is to open up SFU data and encourage developers to consume it. The classic example is the mobile app. There are currently several in the Apple app store that rely on screen scraping to get the job done. We’d like to see that go away and encourage good development by students. This could translate into a better reputation for the university as a leading edge institute.
* close relationship between data management initiatives/governance and our ROA (Resource-Oriented Architecture) Web Services has made the governance of Web Services easier than it might have been otherwise. Also, maintenance has been easier since the number of Web Services roughly equals the number of data domains (a handful) with several endpoints per services which roughly equate to primary data tables (e..g. student). No specialized development to deliver only certain data to certain clients. Biggest benefit may be the cumulative effect on IT culture, that developers now expect there to be APIs for data.
* Promote reuse, easier to maintain
* We are early in the process, but we are seeing some benefits in enabling consumption of identity data and in the integration of cloud-based systems with our on-premise systems.
* Ability of central IT to enable others to get done what they need to. Ability to swap in modern systems of record for legacy systems.
* Re-use of services. Changing integration patterns of copying data locally.
* We’ve switched the strategy from IBM’s MQ and SOAP to REST-style Web API’s secured with OAuth 2.0 access tokens, and have seen much improved interest from the developers in the Divisions. Two Divisions have started developing applications to use the services
* More modern and sustainable integrations. Data transparency and opportunities for distributed app development around the data.
* Lower cost of adoption for new customers. Centralized and consistent security model. Well defined data models have helped to define better APIs.
* Development of mobile applications
* Metrics on usage and types of applications using the data
* Hoping to solve integration challenges. Increased security versus direct database connections.
* Reusability, De-coupling database Discoverability
* Centralizing access to data. Having conversations with people to come up with a consensus to describe data models. Developing one location where developers on campus can go to request access to data and view documentation
* Normalized and consistent abstraction layer to institutional data.

14. What are the primary challenges you’ve seen and are running into with your SOA / API strategy?
* No budget.
* without a strong executive mandate (ala Bezos at Amazon), adoption velocity is slow, especially with established applications that already have privileged access to enterprise administrative data and don’t need to re-invest in a SOA approach. Most success with non-central IT where such privileges don’t exist and with disruptive forces such as new SAAS vendors where data is not easy to get without a SOA approach. Another challenge is the push-back from client developers on our purely RESTful strategy. They often want data preassembled from several REST resources and delivered via a single API call instead doing the assembly themselves. The new EIP will facilitate this requirement.
* Convince developers and show benefits to management
* The ability of the community to ramp up and develop the skill sets necessary to expose services and consume them. We are also having issues with the amount of time it takes for data stewards to approve requests to consume services.
* Unbundling and rebundling complex logic in a new way.
* Everyone wants to consume APIs, nobody wants to contribute.
* The problem with MQ and SOAP was the learning curve for the Divisional developers – they simply didn’t have the time to figure out the details. PHP integration with MQ proved to be a challenge too.
* Prioritization. Funding. Technical debt.
* Early adoption was slow. Skill sets required to be productive are hard to acquire, which in turn slows down the amount of time until a staff memeber can become productive. No centralized documentastion or API gateway for all services to be discovered.
* Resourcing, knowledge, disagreement over approach,
* Governance around data, security, org magement
* Service governance. Getting infrastructure in place.
* Using unproven technology Changing the mindset of people who might be used to doing things in certain way Security, specifically authorization
* There’s an education component of bringing people up to speed with APIs and how to use them. Some people don’t like change and feel that they have less control when they don’t have a local cache of the data.
* Adoption, documentation, technical ability

15. Would you describe your APIs as microservices?

No (explain below)6
I don't know6

No, explained:
* primarily implemented GET functionality which is by nature pretty chunky. Our Web services provide data between apps but don’t encapsulate business functionality except in limited cases. True microservices architecture would require a complete rearchitecture that accounted for eventual consistency and allowed for states of data not currently allowed
* We’re starting to adopt the micorservice model, but at the moment we have a single “student record” service that returns 18 different entities.
* full fledged apis

16. If you have not yet started to work on SOA / API / web services, are you planning to do that in the future?

I don't know1

Note: not all survey participants were presented with this question. Only the ones that previously answered no to question 3.

17. Number of calls per minute for most active web service / API
* N/A
* 100
* 20
* < 1
* 1000
* 200
* Too early in the process to tell.
* N/A
* 3k per minute
* ? – in thousands for the hospital
* NA/Don't know
* N/A
* not live yet

* N/A
* 100
* 20
* < 1
* 1000
* 200
* Too early in the process to tell.
* N/A
* 3k per minute
* ? – in thousands for the hospital
* NA/Don't know
* N/A
* not live yet

18. Number of web services / APIs available
* 5
* 12 each with several different resources
* 20
* 17
* 5-10
* 30 in our API Gateway
* currently 1 service – will be separated into between 10 to 16 micro services
* <10
* 24 APIs
* ~50
* 10
* Less than 12
* less than 15
* not live yet

19. Number of applications using these web services / APIs
* N/A
* 40-60
* 1
* 14
* 10-15
* 300+ Many are student applications
* Two planned for now.
* <10
* 83
* ?
* 10-20
* 5-10
* not live yet

20. Number of departments / organizations using these web services / APIs
* N/A
* 10-20
* 1
* 6
* 3
* Don’t Know
* Two planned for now
* Just internal to IT at this point.
* >25
* ?
* 10-20
* 6-7
* not live yet

21. How much advance notice before API / web service retirement do you provide to your users?
* We anticipate being able to give 1 year notice, but also plan to use API versioning to allow for multiple versions concurrently
* 6 months minimum
* 30 days
* We have allowed the provider to determine that, but our expectation is that it will be at least 18 months.
* NA
* We haven’t retired any services as yet, but we would be expected to provide as much notice as possible because Divisions may not have the resources available to change their consumers.
* I don’t know.
* 4 weeks for production, variable for test environment based on potential affects.
* Not at this level – more adhoc – looking at api manager to support
* Once a web service endpoint is published, it is very difficult to retire.
* N/A
* two years is what we plan to provide

22. What is the granularity of your API versioning?

Single object / resource (e.g.: example.com/api/students/v1/)1
Collection of objects / resources (e.g.: example.com/api/v1/sudents/)8
I don't know3

23. What versioning scheme do your APIs use?

URL: /api/v110
Query parameter: ?v=1.01
HTTP header3

24. From where do you serve query responses? (multiple choice)

Source database14
Intermediate data store / db6
Operational Data Store or Data Warehouse6

Other: code, LDAP

25. What data formats are used by your SOA / Web Services / API layer?


Other: xhtml

26. Which one of these hypermedia formats / types do you use?


27. How were the data models in your SOA / APIs (representation of data objects e.g.: course, student, event) defined?

Single department5
Group of departments6
Data governance5

* collaborative REST design sessions with as many stakeholders involved as possible
* We have to use existing system of record data models.
* Still need to define those

28. Are your data models a direct representation of your database tables / schema?

I don't know0

29. Do you have a data governance initiative?

I don't know0

32. Do you use any tools to automatically convert a db schema / db tables to web service, API or microservice?

I don't know0

34. Does your higher ed institution have a development portal to onboard new developers, including: list of APIs, web services or misc. resources for developers?

I don't know2

36. What type of authentication do you use (e.g., LDAP, SAML, social login,etc) with your development portal?

Social login0

* Basic Auth

37. Is the development portal open to any of the following? (multiple choice)

3rd party developers1

38. What software / technology do you use for the development portal?
* WSO2 API Gateway
* Jive
* WSO2
* WSO2 currently also looking at other solutions

39. Do you use an API Gateway / Management Layer?

I don't know0

46. What types of authentication are required by your higher ed institution to make API / web services calls?
* Public ones: none but will move to access tokens. Private ones: OAuth (still in development)
* UW administered tokens, X509 certs
* ADFS, CAS, Basic Authentication
* set of credentials similar to NetID/password
* Basic Auth, OAuth, CAS, other
* Oauth2.0, WS-Security
* OAuth 2.0 Client Credentials flow – because the users don’t own the data, the University Registrar does. We will consider other flows when the user is actually a Resource Owner.
* API keys, BasicAuth
* WS-Security username token, sometimes client certificates
* jwt
* Username/password, firewall rules
* Oauth
* tokens

47. What types of authentication have you used in the past, that you phased out?
* client certs for very limited SOAP calls
* NA
* basic auth
* none
* n/a
* n/a
* N/A
* ldap
* none

48. Are the authentication tokens, api keys or other authentication methods specific to the application making the request or the user of the application?

Specific to the application9
Specific to the user of the application3
I don't know0

49. What types of security policies do you have in place for making API / web services calls?
* None yet, but planning to move APIs behind the API gateway, use access tokens for all calls, and enforce throttling on public APIs and OAuth for private APIs
* use a home-grown permissions system ASTRA to manage what resources an application can access; applications are assigned roles just like people
* Applications must obtain claims before apps are authorized to use APIs
* In addition to application credentials, the ESB checks with the services registry if the application has approval to use the service. We check the IP addresses of external consumers.
* Depends, some are open, some are highly secured.
* The application making the calls must be assigned a UTORid (the primary identity credential used at UofT). This credential must be used to obtain an OAuth access token, which is then included with API call. There is a policy enforcement point that validates the access tokens. The user’s UTORid is included in the request so that the API container (WebSphere Application Server) can perform authorization.
* IP restricted when possible. Registered API key required.
* AuthNZ at the ESB level to determine who the requester is an dwhether or not they can call the method. At the functional web service layer, a lot of service providers will ask the question what data is returned in the request.
* Under development
* We are in the early stages of defining policies for next generation of APIs.
* It depends on the application
* none yet

50. Do you cache your API responses?

I don't know1

52. How do you handle communication with developers who rely on your APIs, web services regarding upcoming features?


* Yammer
* Personal interaction
* wiki pages

53. What support mechanisms are used by your higher ed institution to provide support of your web services?

Ticket system13

* UserVoice
* Personal interaction

54. What has been your strategy for moving away from bulk data feeds?
* This is a struggle and one we hope to entice people away from with this new API service. That said, private data exchanges (e.g. between our ERP and our meta directory) likely won’t go through the API gateway, but will (we hope) still migrate to an ESB model and away from nightly data dumps.
* still evolving; in fact our new EIP will support bulk feeds as a standard interface for those clients that need/want them. What won’t be supported is direct connection to underlying schema
* We are investigating SOA in a small POC and from there hope to build consensus around moving forward with a larger deployment, institute a governance process, etc.
* Slowly moving away, provide education and training
* We have not settled on a single strategy. Right now, it is mostly in the form of encouragement. At this time, no pre-existing bulk data feeds have been converted. We have architected services into new projects where we would have used bulk data feeds in the past.
* None currently. We have had individual efforts where such a change was suggested or recommended, but the only data transmission method currently used is file transfers.
* Developing ESB, SOA, APIs is the goal but we haven’t started yet. Hope to start a small pilot this coming year.
* Demands that are more real-time in nature have naturally moved us away, but we do still use them sometimes – in fact, we sometimes use API calls to produce the data feeds.
* Many bulk data feeds are used to replicate data into local databases. Local databases are prefered because they are thought to be the only way to provide reliable and timely data to local applications. We are trying to change this pattern by providing APIs.
* Initial approach was to replace batch downloads with real-time transactional messages. We found that the benefit was minimal until the academic or administrative process was changed to accommodate real-time transactions, then the benefit was substantial. However, very few Divisions are ready to change processes even if the benefits were obvious. It needs time for the administrators to think in real-time transactions rather than daily/weekly batch downloads.
* As opportunities arise in existing projects whose contraints allow it, vs. an initiative in of itself.
* We have been suggesting that our high volume bulk curricular data applications use a new service we have for delivering roster changes to JMS queues in an asynchronous manner. We are also delivering HR data to our UW System customers via our centralized HR system to UW System HR systems for local provisioning. We still have some large pull customers that use SOAP services to refresh their local databases, but work is underway to enhance what we can deliver asychrously
* Replace with services
* Still in the early stages
* Show the value of real time data and/or events
* Start by tackling only new work and integrations. Add desirable features to APIs.

56. How was the communication to the developers handled throughout the migration away from bulk data feeds?
* We’ll see.
* hasn’t happened yet
* We’ve not gotten that far yet.
* Provide education and training
* N/a
* Through architecture engagements with individual projects.
* The problem was we started with the developers – we should have started with the senior administrators by describing the benefits to their processes and increase in data currency…and not mention technology at all!
* Ad hoc, project by project.
* Email and meetings
* This is still work in progress.
* N/A
* Since API initiative is very new, we are hoping to have results available in next 3-4 years
* not applicable yet.

57. What are the top 3 SOA / API problems you’re trying to solve?
* – Get an operational gateway in service – Retire SOAP and associated legacy support applications – Move to real-time exchange of information between systems
* Top 7: integration with metadata management strategy and tools; granular data element level security; increased velocity building new APIs; better managed application management; cross-domain APIs; highly-performant search; produce more events for client apps
* 1. How to do it (Authentication, stumbling blocks, good default design patterns to champion). 2. How to illustrate the value of this effort to upper management to allocate funds. 3. How to navigate the political waters
* Easier access management; Reduce development complexity; Fit for cloud and mobile first strategy
* (1) Adoption (2) Slowness in data steward approvals (3) Strengthening security
* Getting interest/ buy-in from the web/portal team Training/obtaining staff with the skills to facilitate this move – Analysts and developers with actual API and SOA experience Lack of understanding/ prioritization from IT executives around this importance of this architectural change.
* 3) simplification/feed elimination 2) timely data 1) flexibility for apps mash-ups, mobile, etc.
* Improve speed of innovation Migrate away from legacy systems Improve user experience
* Getting enough re-usable content in our API Directory Providing training to developers Changing the culture to make exposing data to our community of developers an important deliverable for projects
* secure real-time access to student data in the System of Record, rather than stale local copies near real-time synchronization of identity management repositories –
* Exposure or data to innovators around campus. More modern, real-time, sustainable integrations. Overall efficiency, maximizing reuse instead of duplicated bulk jobs.
* API management Continuous integration within our SOA environments Oauth or Identity Server provided credentials for client side javascript that would access our servers from client side Javascript.
* Improve integration with campus and 3rd party systems More secure access to data by campuses and 3rd party systems Promote re-use of business functions Promote innovative uses of
* Authorization Canonical data model API Governance
* RFP for API Gateway Automation Developing APIs that make business sense

58. What’s your higher ed institution’s 5-year plan for SOA / API / Web Services?
* Get a production service rolled out that is actively used by the university community. Hopefully secure budget to manage it one day.
* Build an Enterprise Integration Platform to replace ODS and to feed EDW and migrate existing Web Services to to be hosted from EIP; Govern EIP holistically as part of larger data management initiative
* To say we have a 5-year plan for Web Services is to give us more credit for planning than I believe we deserve at the moment. Right now we’re trying to build momentum and doing so in a guerilla fashion as part of smaller projects in the hopes we can scale this effort in the future.
* Moving away from batch processes to ESB and service automation
* More adoption
* Last time I spoke with the teams about it, no plan existed other than ad-hoc development as required by selected projects. And those projects are generally rejected due to lack of supportability.
* Not there yet.
* Don’t Know
* We’re waiting to see what our experience is with our current approach (REST/OAuth 2.0) and if successful, focus on API management (we’ll probably buy a product).
* I don’t know.
* Build an Integration Center of Excellence for our campus.
* Still in planning and proof-of-concept phase. Evaluating cloud API management solutions.
* Have around 100+ apis
* Start by centrally providing APIs Develop a foundation such as: docs, testing, infrastructure that others can leverage Get other departments on campus to develop APIs using best practices provided centrally In 3 years, we’d like APIs to be the main method of transferring data between departments.

59. What are your areas and topics of interest for SOA?
* API Gateway deployment, currently
* security metadata
* We would like to see it in action at a larger scale and the effect it has had on productivity. We would be interested in discussing architecture and infrastructure decisions to learn from those. At this time we are primarily leaning toward an ESB-based platform offering web services, primarily RESTful, as our approach.
* ERP system integration and mobile apps
* (1) OAuth 2 (2) Adoption strategies (3) API Management Tools (4) Approval workflows and automation of approval workflows (5) Strategies for working effectively with data stewards (6) Documentation tools
* Real time data exchange. Improved accuracy of data Improved security architecture
* API sharing for common things that we do in higher ed.
* Is there an opportunity to define a common API for all universities to implement? http://edutechnica.com/2015/06/09/flipping-the-model-the-campus-api/ (I’m george.kroner@umuc.edu)
* Governance, governance, governance.
* ESB to iPaaS change in the higher ed market. Empowering innovative developers with data. Establishment of shared APIs as a path to more sane, governed, transparent, sustainable integration landscape in IT.
* REST, APIs, Authentication, Authorization, Organizational
* Already listed on ITANA site
* developing APIs speeding up the process through automation

Posted in API.